Easton Historic District Commission Meeting – November 9, 2026
The one where a packed room and a former mayor save the old bus station.
In 60 seconds
- Old bus station: The commission denied a plan to tear down the former bus terminal at 102 Bushkill Street and build a six-story apartment building. 2:28:24
- Residents speak out: Preservation Easton, a realtor speaking for more than 100 neighbors, and several residents urged denial, citing the building’s history, skyline view and scale. 1:33:20
- Developer’s case: The developers said flood rules make reusing the building financially unworkable and offered to echo its rounded corners and brick bands in a new design. 1:21:05
- Front steps on hold: A coating on the front steps at 122 North Second Street was tabled; commissioners will visit the site to discuss staining. 26:22
- Tattoo studio approved: A tattoo and piercing studio at 137-139 Northampton Street won approval for window signs, with the large center sign reduced 15 to 20 percent. 19:18

City of Easton, 5 PM
City Council Chambers, Third Floor, Easton City Hall, 123 S. 3rd Street, Easton, PA 18042
Documented by: Laini Abraham
Posted on: Nov 11, 2026
The full meeting, section by section
Press play on the video first. Then select any time below to jump to that part of the meeting. On a phone, this takes you back up to the video.
Meeting opens
The commission met with a quorum present, with members Mario Guarriello, Clay Mitman, Phil Mitman, Chelsea Morrese and Dwayne Tillman answering roll call. October 12 minutes were approved.
Ferry Street trim repair approved
The commission approved replacing rotted trim in kind at 525 Ferry Street as submitted. The consultant said the failure likely came from missing or poor flashing and recommended finding all sources of water infiltration. Comcast did not appear on old business.
Larry Holmes Drive roof approved
S&G Real Estate Enterprises won approval to replace the roof at 310-390 Larry Holmes Drive with GAF Slateline shingles in antique slate.
- The approval does not expire, so the owners can work in phases.
What’s next: The approval goes to City Council, about two to four weeks, before a permit issues.
Three front windows approved on Ferry Street
The commission approved replacing three front windows at 524 Ferry Street with Marvin aluminum-clad wood 6-over-6 windows. Samantha Porter spoke for owner Peter Wayne.
Tattoo studio signs approved with smaller window sign
North Easton LLC’s tattoo and piercing studio, Fifth Layer, won approval for signs at 137-139 Northampton Street. The large center window sign must shrink 15 to 20 percent.
- Staff said the applicants will likely exceed the two signs per frontage allowed and should check with zoning.
- Frosting on the windows was postponed.
Front step coating tabled for site visit
The commission tabled a request to approve a top coat already applied to the front steps and landing at 122 North Second Street. The consultant said the broom finish is not historically appropriate and suggested light grinding or staining. Applicant Lucka Greco was open to a site visit.
- The coating appeared to be a Mapei product, possibly Mapefloor Finish 450.
What’s next: Two commissioners will visit the site and test a stain sample; the applicant’s email is on the application.
Brick replacement at nursing home approved
Maybrook-P Easton Propco LLC won approval to replace spalling brick at the Gardens of Easton, 498 Washington Street, on the condition that it provides mortar and water-source information directly to the consultant. The representative, Brendan, said he works for Frank Gaffney’s company. The consultant said mortar should be softer than the new brick.
Law office fence approved
PD 91 LHD LLC, with Seth Tipton, won approval for a 4-foot black aluminum fence and a dumpster enclosure at 91 Larry Holmes Drive. No gate is planned. Peggy Palmer asked about the old wood fence, which is being removed. A commissioner recused.
Spring Garden roof approved with ridge caps
The commission approved a roof replacement at 106 Spring Garden Street as submitted, with rolled ridge caps required. The finial and chimney repair were recommended, not required. The contractor said work begins in two weeks.
South Fifth Street stoop approved with changes
The commission approved rebuilding the front stoop and stair at 43 South Fifth Street, with Craig Nush presenting. Conditions are full-thickness brick instead of thin brick and a more ornamental railing.
What’s next: The applicant will resubmit a railing image to the consultant, who can approve it without another meeting if it meets the intent.
Last slate sidewalk replaced with concrete
Scott Quality Products won approval to replace about 10 feet of deteriorated slate sidewalk at 26 North Second Street with concrete. Commissioners called it a shame but agreed it was unsafe. Marc Devlin asked about avoiding white patches; the consultant said ordinary concrete blends in better than tinted.
Consultant says bus terminal should be saved
The commission heard a proposal to demolish the former bus terminal at 102 Bushkill Street and build a six-story, 74-foot apartment building with parking on the first floor. The application lists Dorothy Varju and Mary Sue Tumminello as owners. Kevin Serfass presented the plan. Consultant Christine Ussler said the 1946 building is historically significant and the demolition application lacked required evidence.
- She said the flood plain does not bar reuse, citing a historic-building exception.
- She said the new building would block the view of the city from the eastern gateway.
Developers argue flood rules make reuse unworkable
The developers said the building is outside the 1983 National Register period (through 1924) and is not true streamline architecture. They said flood rules triggered by 50 percent improvements make reuse infeasible, and presented a financial feasibility study.
- They described the project as an Upper East Side and said it is below zoning limits.
- They said they could echo rounded corners, brick banding and window patterns, and called it a better match to the former Seitz Brewing and Bottling Company.
Christopher Mitman asks to deny demolition
Christopher Mitman, a sixth-generation resident and realtor, said he spoke for over 100 neighbors who signed his letter. He asked the commission to deny demolition and require retention and restoration of the building, and to enter his letter and renderings into the record.
(Christopher Mitman is the son of Commissioner Clay Mitman.)
Paul Felder says project is out of context
Paul Felder, speaking for Preservation Easton, said the building does not fit Bushkill Street’s context and would block the skyline view from the bridge. He said the project has 48 parking spaces for 59 units and called the building a rare streamline modern example. He said similar projects have been built over older buildings elsewhere in Easton.
Dennis Lieb questions plans and zoning intent
Dennis Lieb, a Preservation Easton member and one of eight citizens who wrote the 2007 zoning rewrite, said the rendering misstates the site and neighboring parking. He said the design ignores zoning goals on setbacks, height placement and street-level activity. He proposed a transportation and brewing museum for the site.
Patty Price wants reuse like a theater or rink
Patty Price said she is opposed to demolition and the larger building. She suggested the building could house a movie theater, restaurant or roller skating rink and said downtown has enough large apartment buildings.
Jeff Martinson cites demolition criteria
Jeff Martinson urged denial. He said the application did not show clear danger, rehabilitation feasibility, lack of historic significance or compatibility.
Cody Harding cites sign code and entrance view
Cody Harding urged denial. He said the new building would obstruct the entrance into Easton and cited the large temporary sign limit in the zoning code, saying the developer put up an unauthorized billboard.
Brett Weber urges thoughtful reuse
Brett Weber, an architect and Preservation Easton co-chair, said reuse is the best stewardship and that flood plain issues can be worked through. He rejected the idea that approval should hinge on a bigger alternative, and urged denial.
Commissioners question developers on height and structure
Developers said they considered going taller and chose six stories because the zoning allows more. They said the building is structurally sound but needs new systems, and that they looked at building over it but chose a design echoing its features.
Commission denies bus terminal demolition
The commission voted to deny demolition and the proposed new building at 102 Bushkill Street. Commissioner Phil Mitman, a former mayor, described his long preservation record, said he would vote to deny, and made the motion. Commissioner Clay Mitman recused, saying he owns the adjacent properties. The motion passed on a voice vote with no opposition. The presenters left right after the vote.
What’s next: The applicant may pursue other city boards.
Adjournment
The chair thanked attendees for staying late, and the commission adjourned on a motion and second.
CONTENTS