This was our first time here, and it is officially a new favorite! We tried the housemade broccoli & cheddar rice balls and the Jersey Pie, and everything was absolutely delicious.
The Jersey Pie is their classic upside-down pizza topped with housemade meatballs and ricotta, and it was incredible! The flavors went together perfectly. The rice balls were also amazing — topped with ranch and cooked to perfection.
Next time we visit, I definitely want to try the zeppoles because they looked so good, but we were completely stuffed after finishing the pizza!
I can’t wait to come back and try more. If you’re in the area, this place is definitely worth checking out!
This is easily one of the best restaurants I have ever been too. I was here the first time a few days ago to celebrate a family member’s birthday and I was blown away. I got the ravioli with vodka sauce… literally to die for. The vodka sauce is the best I have ever had; I literally ate spoonfuls of it by itself. 11/10 recommend!
Colonial Pizza has delicious upside down pizza and their sauce is amazing. Calamari is tender and perfectly cooked. The Founders wings are tender, juicy, spicy and craveable. The only negative about anything Ive had there, the side salad lacks, well , everything. It’s shredded iceberg lettuce with diced tomatoes and onions. Go today! You won’t be disappointed (unless you order the salad😂).
Went here with my family last night for Mother’s Day. Atmosphere was cozy, we sat at the window. Staff were very professional and friendly, checked on us throughout dinner to ensure we were satisfied. My son loved the waitress, which surprised me since he is very shy when it comes to interacting with strangers. Food portions were HUGE, priced matched the portion size. Very affordable. I ordered a drink and boy was it strong, they were not shy with the alcohol. I loved it, and can’t wait to try it in the summer for the outdoor seating.
Melissa Ferrani
This was our first time here, and it is officially a new favorite! We tried the housemade broccoli & cheddar rice balls and the Jersey Pie, and everything was absolutely delicious.
The Jersey Pie is their classic upside-down pizza topped with housemade meatballs and ricotta, and it was incredible! The flavors went together perfectly. The rice balls were also amazing — topped with ranch and cooked to perfection.
Next time we visit, I definitely want to try the zeppoles because they looked so good, but we were completely stuffed after finishing the pizza!
I can’t wait to come back and try more. If you’re in the area, this place is definitely worth checking out!
Payton Mentzer
This is easily one of the best restaurants I have ever been too. I was here the first time a few days ago to celebrate a family member’s birthday and I was blown away. I got the ravioli with vodka sauce… literally to die for. The vodka sauce is the best I have ever had; I literally ate spoonfuls of it by itself. 11/10 recommend!
Josh Reddinger
Great amd fast service. Awesome food and a great beer list too
Kim Montgomery
Colonial Pizza has delicious upside down pizza and their sauce is amazing. Calamari is tender and perfectly cooked. The Founders wings are tender, juicy, spicy and craveable. The only negative about anything Ive had there, the side salad lacks, well , everything. It’s shredded iceberg lettuce with diced tomatoes and onions. Go today! You won’t be disappointed (unless you order the salad😂).
Jamie-Lee Perry
Went here with my family last night for Mother’s Day. Atmosphere was cozy, we sat at the window. Staff were very professional and friendly, checked on us throughout dinner to ensure we were satisfied. My son loved the waitress, which surprised me since he is very shy when it comes to interacting with strangers.
Food portions were HUGE, priced matched the portion size. Very affordable.
I ordered a drink and boy was it strong, they were not shy with the alcohol.
I loved it, and can’t wait to try it in the summer for the outdoor seating.