Small mom and pop pizza shop. Only 2 small tables and 4 chairs. Several salad options that looked amazing. Our pizza was the meatlovers and was delicious. The crust was awesome. Thank you Anthony and Nicole. Joe and Sharon
We’ve been coming to Moonlight for 6 months or so now and we absolutely love the pizza and the owners! Always consistent and absolutely delicious. You can tell the time and effort that is put into making the pizzas! They are absolutely lovely people and super kind! If we lived closer it would be a weekly stop!
I am a pizza snob. I have lived 15 minutes from Moonlight for nearly a year and just found out about it from Barstool. Best pizza I have had in recent memory. Cannot wait to go back
Heard about Moonlight Pizza after it was reviewed by Dave Portnoy’s pizza series on YouTube. We had to call many, many times to get the pies reserved for pickup in the evening, but it was well worth it and some of the best pizza we’ve ever had! For perspective, this is coming from two people who lived in the NJ/NY area for many years. The crust and dough underneath were crispy, well done, fluffy on the outer edges, and able to support all the toppings on both the cheese pie and bacon & and caramelized onion pie. The sauce on the cheese pizza was balanced, not too sweet or sour. The bacon & caramelized onion pie was savory. Can’t wait to go back!
Sharon Reilly
Small mom and pop pizza shop. Only 2 small tables and 4 chairs. Several salad options that looked amazing. Our pizza was the meatlovers and was delicious. The crust was awesome. Thank you Anthony and Nicole. Joe and Sharon
E Miller
Totally worth the hype and 30 min drive. The crust was excellent. The owners were so very nice.
Stephanie Green
We’ve been coming to Moonlight for 6 months or so now and we absolutely love the pizza and the owners! Always consistent and absolutely delicious. You can tell the time and effort that is put into making the pizzas! They are absolutely lovely people and super kind! If we lived closer it would be a weekly stop!
Justin Faucette
I am a pizza snob. I have lived 15 minutes from Moonlight for nearly a year and just found out about it from Barstool. Best pizza I have had in recent memory. Cannot wait to go back
David S
Heard about Moonlight Pizza after it was reviewed by Dave Portnoy’s pizza series on YouTube. We had to call many, many times to get the pies reserved for pickup in the evening, but it was well worth it and some of the best pizza we’ve ever had! For perspective, this is coming from two people who lived in the NJ/NY area for many years. The crust and dough underneath were crispy, well done, fluffy on the outer edges, and able to support all the toppings on both the cheese pie and bacon & and caramelized onion pie. The sauce on the cheese pizza was balanced, not too sweet or sour. The bacon & caramelized onion pie was savory. Can’t wait to go back!